Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites - MathOverflow

Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-09T10:32:48Z

What are the simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposite rings? Is there a science to constructing them?

The only simple example known to me:

In Jacobson's Basic Algebra (vol. 1), Section 2.8, there is an exercise that goes as follows:

Let $u=\begin{pmatrix} 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 1\\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}\in M_3(\mathbf Q)$ and let $x=\begin{pmatrix} u & 0 \\ 0 & u^2 \end{pmatrix}$ , $y=\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\0&0\end{pmatrix}$ , where $u$ is as indicated and $0$ and $1$ are zero and unit matrices in $M_3(\mathbf Q)$. Hence $x,y\in M_6(\mathbf Q)$ . Jacobson gives hints to prove that the subring of $M_6(\mathbf Q)$ generated by $x$ and $y$ is not isomorphic to its opposite.

Examples seem to be well-known to the operator algebras crowd:

See for example the paper: "A Simple Separable C*-Algebra Not Isomorphic to Its Opposite Algebra" by N. Christopher Phillips, Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society Vol. 132, No. 10 (Oct., 2004), pp. 2997-3005.

Answer by Bugs Bunny for Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-09T11:00:15Z

Your example is not simple, i.e., it is not a simple algebra! If you want a simple algebra, you need a field whose Brauer group has elements of order more than 2 (the opposite algebra = inversion in Brauer group). If I remember correctly, the p-adic field will do the trick...

Answer by Pete L. Clark for Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-09T11:51:26Z

To amplify on Bugs Bunny's answer: let $D$ be a finite dimensional central division algebra over a field $K$. Then $D \otimes_K D^{\operatorname{op}} \cong \operatorname{End}_K(D)$. From this it follows that in the Brauer group of $K$, the class of $D^{\operatorname{op}}$ is the inverse of the class of $D$. So a central division algebra over a field is isomorphic to its opposite algebra iff it has order $2$ in the Brauer group, or, in the lingo of that field, period $2$.

So you can get examples by taking any field $K$ with $\operatorname{Br}(K) \neq \operatorname{Br}(K)[2]$. In particular the Brauer group of any non-Archimedean locally compact field is $\mathbb{Q}/\mathbb{Z}$ and the Brauer group of any global field is close to being the direct sum of the Brauer groups of its completions (there is one relation, the so-called reciprocity law, which says that a certain "sum of invariants" map is zero). So for instance a division algebra of dimension $9$ over its center will do and these things can be constructed over the above fields.

If you don't want to restrict to such nice algebras, it becomes much easier to construct examples. (Thanks to L. Moret-Bailly and Todd Trimble for fixing this!) Let $S$ be a set with at least two elements, and consider the left semigroup on $S$: for all $x,y \in S$, $x \cdot y = x$. For any field $K$, let $K[S]$ be the semigroup algebra, and let $A = K[S]^1 = K \oplus K[S]$ be the associated unital algebra. Then, if I am not still mistaken, it should be clear that $A$ is not isomorphic to its opposite algebra.

(Since I know nothing about operator algebras, my opinion is of course going to be that such examples are much more complicated than the ones given above...)

Answer by Martin Brandenburg for Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-09T12:15:48Z

Here is an easy example. Consider the abelian group $M = \mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{Q}$. I claim that $R:=\text{End}(M)$ does not have any anti-endomorphism at all. EDIT: My previous proof is flawed. Thanks to Leon Lampret who pointed this out to me. The new proof shows that $R$ has several anti-endomorphisms, but no one is invertible. Thus $R$ is not isomorphic to $R^{\mathrm{op}}$.

Identify $R$ with the matrix ring $\begin{pmatrix} \mathbb{Z} & 0 \\ \mathbb{Q} & \mathbb{Q} \end{pmatrix}$. The endomorphism ring of the underlying abelian group $\mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{Q} \times \mathbb{Q}$ of $R$ can be identified with the matrix ring $\begin{pmatrix} \mathbb{Z} & 0 & 0 \\ \mathbb{Q} & \mathbb{Q} & \mathbb{Q} \\ \mathbb{Q} & \mathbb{Q} & \mathbb{Q} \end{pmatrix}$.

Assume an anti-endomorphism $\alpha$ of $R$ is given by such a matrix $\begin{pmatrix}a & 0 & 0 \\ b & c & d \\ e & f & g \end{pmatrix}$.

Then $\alpha(1)=1$ yields $a=1, b+d=0, e+g=1$. The determinant is $cg-df$. For all six-tuples $(u,v,w,p,q,r)$ (with $u,p$ integer) we have

$\alpha\left(\begin{pmatrix} u & 0 \\ v & w \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} p & 0 \\ q & r \end{pmatrix}\right) = \alpha \begin{pmatrix} p & 0 \\ q & r \end{pmatrix} \alpha\begin{pmatrix} u & 0 \\ v & w \end{pmatrix}$

which yields the three equations

1) $a^2 pu = pu$

2) $ap(bu + cv + dw) + (bp + cq + dr)(eu + fv + gw) = bpu + c(qu + rv) + drw$

3) $(ep + fq + gr)(eu + fv + gw) = epu + f(qu + rv) + grw$

If we plug in the three equations we already know from $\alpha(1)=1$, this simplifies of course. Now insert some tuples to get the following equations:

$(0,1,0,0,1,0) \leadsto f^2 = 0 \Rightarrow f = 0$

$(0,1,0,1,0,0) \leadsto c = 0$

This already shows that the determinant of $\alpha$ is zero, thus $\alpha$ cannot be bijective. But we can go even further:

$(1,0,0,1,0,0) \leadsto be=0 \wedge e^2=e \Rightarrow e \in \{0,1\}$

For $e = 0$ we get

$\alpha=\begin{pmatrix}1 & 0 & 0 \\ b & 0 & -b \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}$

and for $e=1$ we get

$\alpha=\begin{pmatrix}1 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 1 & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}$.

Here $b \in \mathbb{Q}$ may be chosen arbitrary. These are all anti-endomorphisms of $R$.

There is a more advanced proof that $R$ is not isomorphic to $R^{\mathrm{op}}$: Observe that $R$ is right noetherian, but not left noetherian.

Answer by James Cranch for Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-09T13:02:15Z

Here's a factory for making examples. If $\Gamma$ is a quiver, and $k$ a field, then we get a quiver algebra $k\Gamma$. If $\Gamma$ has no oriented cycles, we can recover $\Gamma$ from $k\Gamma$ by taking the Ext-construction. Also, the opposite algebra of a quiver algebra is obtained by reversing all the arrows in the quiver.

Hence you can produce an example by taking the quiver algebra of any quiver with no oriented cycles, which is not isomorphic to its reverse. It's easy to construct lots of quivers with these properties.

Answer by Tom De Medts for Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-09T13:06:37Z

Here is an explicit example of a central simple algebra over $\mathbb{Q}$ not isomorphic to its opposite (which is merely a detailed example of what Pete explained).

First take a cubic cyclic Galois extension $L/\mathbb{Q}$, for instance $L = \mathbb{Q}[x] / (x^3 + x^2 − 2x − 1)$, and let $\rho$ be a non-trivial element of $\operatorname{Gal}(L/\mathbb{Q})$. Now take an arbitrary element $\gamma \in \mathbb{Q}$ which is not the norm of an element in $L$. Define $$D = L \oplus zL \oplus z^2L,$$ where $z$ is a new "symbol" subject to the relations $z^3 = \gamma$ and $zt = t^\rho z$ for all $t \in L$. Then $D$ is a central simple division algebra of degree $3$ (i.e. of dimension $9$), and since its image in $\operatorname{Br}(\mathbb{Q})$ has order $3$, it is not isomorphic to its opposite.

As you can imagine, this procedure works for any field admitting a cyclic extension (of degree $>2$) for which the norm is non-surjective.

Answer by cdouglas for Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-09T13:34:54Z

A particularly simple example of an algebra not isomorphic to its (graded) opposite is the $\mathbb{R}$-algebra $\mathbb{C}$, where $1$ is even and $i$ is odd. This is the ($\mathbb{Z}/2$-graded) real Clifford algebra $Cl(-1) = \langle f \mid f^2 = -1 \rangle$. Its opposite is the Clifford algebra $Cl(1) = \langle e \mid e^2 = 1 \rangle$, whose underlying ungraded algebra is isomorphic to $\mathbb{R} \oplus \mathbb{R}$.

Per the discussion in the other answers, these two algebras represent $1$ and $-1 = 7$ in the graded Brauer group $\mathbb{Z}/8$ of $\mathbb{R}$.

Answer by F. Ladisch for Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-09T16:20:48Z

A general idea to construct rings which behave different on the left and on the right is the following, which is already contained in Martins's answer: One considers triangular rings $$ A=\begin{pmatrix} R & M \\ 0 & S \end{pmatrix} $$ where $R$ and $S$ are rings and $M$ is an $R$-$S$-bimodule. The left and right ideals of such a ring can be decribed: for example, the left ideals are isomorphic to $U\oplus J$, where $J $ is a left ideal of $S$, and $U$ an $R$-submodule of $R\oplus M$ with $MJ \subseteq U$. (See Lam's book A First Course in Noncommutative Rings, §1) Suitable choices of $R$, $M$ and $S$ lead to examples with quite different left and right structure. For example, the finite ring $$\begin{pmatrix} \mathbb{Z}/4\mathbb{Z} & \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} \\ 0 & \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} \end{pmatrix}$$ has 11 left ideals and 12 right ideals, if my counting is right. (This may be the smallest example of a unital ring not isomorphic to its opposite ring, but I'm not sure here.)

Of course, there are lots of examples, since there are many ring theoretic notions which are known to be not left-right symmetric. T. Y. Lam, in his two books (First Course mentioned above and Lectures on Modules and Rings), usually contructs at least one example of a ring being left blah but not right blah, whenever blah is a property which is not left-right symmetric. (Lam's books are generally worth reading, in particular when looking for examples!)

Answer by Thomas Nevins for Simplest examples of rings that are not isomorphic to their opposites

2011-05-10T14:56:49Z

Hi Amri,

This is a bit late, but it's my favorite class of examples. If $X$ is a smooth affine variety over $\mathbb{C}$ (say), and $\mathcal{D} = \mathcal{D}(X)$ is its algebra of differential operators, then the opposite algebra $\mathcal{D}^{op}$ is isomorphic to $\mathcal{D}(K) = K\otimes \mathcal{D}\otimes K^{-1}$, where $K$ denotes the canonical module of $X$. [This is also true when $X$ is Gorenstein but not necessarily smooth---see work of Yekutieli.]

So one gets answers to your question when $X$ doesn't have trivial canonical bundle. [And of course the story sheafifies for any smooth variety.]

EDIT: I was writing carelessly the first time (thanks to Amri's comment for highlighting this). Note that $\mathcal{D}(K)$ acts on $K$ on the left. Since a left $\mathcal{D}$-module structure on a vector bundle (finitely generated projective module) is the same as a flat connection, one has $\mathcal{D}\cong \mathcal{D}(K)$ if and only if $K$ admits a flat connection. The first chern class of $K$ is an obstruction to the existence of a flat connection. So just pick your favorite such affine variety (see also this MO question for discussion of that). A pretty complete discussion of the (non)triviality of rings of twisted differential operators (TDOs) can be found in Beilinson-Bernstein "A proof of Jantzen conjectures."

This story also illuminates a little bit why differential operators on half-densities, i.e. $\mathcal{D}(K^{1/2}) = K^{1/2}\otimes \mathcal{D}\otimes K^{-1/2}$, plays a special role in the study of rings of differential operators and (twisted) $\mathcal{D}$-modules (it's canonically isomorphic to its opposite algebra).