Why do sl(2) and so(3) correspond to different points on the Vogel plane? - MathOverflow most recent 30 from http://mathoverflow.net 2013-05-22T18:09:11Z http://mathoverflow.net/feeds/question/63943 http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.5/rdf http://mathoverflow.net/questions/63943/why-do-sl2-and-so3-correspond-to-different-points-on-the-vogel-plane Why do sl(2) and so(3) correspond to different points on the Vogel plane? Noah Snyder 2011-05-04T19:19:00Z 2011-05-04T20:26:25Z <p>Vogel assigns to every simple metric Lie algebra (and more generally to every simple metric Lie algebra object in a symmetric monoidal category) a point in the orbifold \$\mathbb{P}^2/S_3\$ (where \$S_3\$ acts by permuting the 3 projective coordinates) based on the value of the Casimir on the various summands of the symmetric square of the adjoint representation. These three numbers are only defined up to permutation (as there's no natural way to specify which rep is which) and rescaling (because the Casimir itself is only well-defined up to rescaling).</p> <p>Under this assignment we have \$\mathfrak{sl}_2\$ and \$\mathfrak{so}_3\$ going to different points. How is this possible? My best guess is that \$\mathfrak{sl}_2\$ and \$\mathfrak{so}_3\$ are different as metric Lie algebras, but that also seems weird.</p> <p>In the conventions of <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.0115" rel="nofollow">this paper</a> \$\mathfrak{sl}_2\$ corresponds to the point \$(-1:1:1)\$ while \$\mathfrak{so}_3\$ corresponds to the point \$(-1:2:-1)\$ and these are different points in \$\mathbb{P}^2/S_3\$. You can also easily check that the points are different in <a href="http://www.math.tamu.edu/~jml/LMunivpub.pdf" rel="nofollow">other</a> <a href="http://www.warwick.ac.uk/~masdbn/home.html" rel="nofollow">convetions</a>.</p> <p>This question was originally asked in <a href="http://mathoverflow.net/questions/63033/what-would-you-want-on-a-lie-theory-cheat-poster/63066#63066" rel="nofollow">comments</a> by Scott Carnahan, but I wanted to move it up to the main page.</p> http://mathoverflow.net/questions/63943/why-do-sl2-and-so3-correspond-to-different-points-on-the-vogel-plane/63946#63946 Answer by Bruce Westbury for Why do sl(2) and so(3) correspond to different points on the Vogel plane? Bruce Westbury 2011-05-04T20:26:25Z 2011-05-04T20:26:25Z <p>I take it you mean \$\mathfrak{sl}_2\$ is on the line \$\mathfrak{sl}_n\$ and \$\mathfrak{so}_3\$ is on the line \$\mathfrak{so}_n\$. There is no contradiction because there is a whole line for this metric Lie algebra. The symmetric square of the adjoint decomposes as the trivial representation (which is accounted for by the Killing form) and one other irreducible (of dimension 5). This means you only have one of the three coordinates. Usually the coordinates are the values of the quadratic Casimir on the three non-trivial factors of the symmetric square of the adjoint representation. However looking at the adjoint representation you also know the sum of the three coordinates. This determines a line in the Vogel plane.</p>