Intersection of an affine cubic and quartic: at least nine points? - MathOverflow most recent 30 from http://mathoverflow.net2013-05-22T11:49:44Zhttp://mathoverflow.net/feeds/question/56689http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.5/rdfhttp://mathoverflow.net/questions/56689/intersection-of-an-affine-cubic-and-quartic-at-least-nine-pointsIntersection of an affine cubic and quartic: at least nine points?Spryngli2011-02-25T23:28:23Z2011-02-26T10:16:32Z
<p>Hello,
I have posed myself the following problem: suppose that two affine algebraic with no common components curves be given. To fix ideas, suppose that we have a cubic $C$ and a quartic $D$.
More precisely, let $C={(u,v)\in C^2\colon P(u,v)=0}$ and $D={(u,v)\in C^2\colon Q(u,v)=0}$, with $P$ and $Q$ polynomials and $deg(P)=3$, $deg(Q)=4$.
Could we say that $C\cap D\cap \mathbb{C}^2$ has at least 9 points?</p>
<p>I have also worked out an answer, (which should be: yes). All points are to be counted with multiplicity.
Let $\tilde C$ and $\tilde D$ be the projective extensions of $C$ and $D$: $\tilde C$ has three points at infinity and $\tilde D$ has four, so $\tilde C \cap \tilde D$ has at most three points at infinity.
Now we can apply Bézout’s theorem: we have that $\tilde C$ and $\tilde D$ intersect in exactly twelve points. This implies that $C\cap D\cap \mathbb{C}^2$ has at least $12-3=9$ points, QED.
It seems correct to me, but still something sounds wrong.
Many thanks for any answers or comments.</p>
http://mathoverflow.net/questions/56689/intersection-of-an-affine-cubic-and-quartic-at-least-nine-points/56696#56696Answer by aaron for Intersection of an affine cubic and quartic: at least nine points?aaron2011-02-26T02:06:47Z2011-02-26T02:06:47Z<p>It is possible for all 12 intersection points to be at infinity (remember that they are counted with multiplicity). For instance you might have seven parallel lines, as Georges said.</p>
http://mathoverflow.net/questions/56689/intersection-of-an-affine-cubic-and-quartic-at-least-nine-points/56703#56703Answer by Sándor Kovács for Intersection of an affine cubic and quartic: at least nine points?Sándor Kovács2011-02-26T04:11:36Z2011-02-26T04:11:36Z<p>Your proof is correct if and only $C$ and $D$ intersect transversally on the line at infinity. In other words all the intersection points at infinity have multiplicity $1$ as you assume in your proof. The correct statement is that you get $12-m$ intersection points where $m$ is the number of intersection points at infinity counted with multiplicity. This $m$ could be anything between $0$ and $12$.</p>