Is S_6 the automorphism group of a group? - MathOverflow

Is S_6 the automorphism group of a group?

2009-10-19T16:59:49Z

The automorphism group of the symmetric group S_n is S_n when n is not 2 or 6, in which cases it is respectively 1 and the semidirect product of S_6 with the (cyclic) group of order 2. (For this famous outer automorphism, see for instance wikipedia or Baez's thoughts on the number 6.)

On the other hand, S_2 is the automorphism group of Z_3, Z_4 and Z_6 (and only those groups among finite groups). Hence my question: is S_6 the automorphism group of a group? of a finite group?

Answer by Steven Sivek for Is S_6 the automorphism group of a group?

2009-10-19T17:57:48Z

S_6 is not the automorphism group of a finite group. See H.K. Iyer, "On solving the equation Aut(X)=G", Rocky Mountain J. Math. 9 (1979), no. 4, 653--670, available online here.

This paper proves that for any finite group G, there are finitely many finite groups X with Aut(X)=G, and it explicitly solves the equation for some specific values of G. In particular, Theorem 4.4 gives the complete solution for G a symmetric group, and when n=6 there are no such X.

Answer by David Zureick-Brown for Is S_6 the automorphism group of a group?

2009-10-19T18:20:15Z

On the other hand, S_6 is isomorphic to SL_4(F_2), so that it is an automorphism group in another category (other than groups or sets). This automorphism is exhibited by looking at the 2-torsion of the Jacobian of a hyperelliptic curve H of genus 2 (if H is given by y^2 = f(x), with f of degree 6, then 15 non-trivial two torsion points are given [as a Galois module] by differences of roots of f; see the wiki page for Kummer surface).

Answer by Jim Fowler for Is S_6 the automorphism group of a group?

2009-10-19T19:12:06Z

It's probably worth pointing to

Belolipetsky, Mikhail; Lubotzky, Alexander. Finite groups and hyperbolic manifolds. Invent. Math. 162 (2005), no. 3, 459-472. MR2198218.

where it is shown that for every finite group G, there's an infinite group Gamma with Out(Gamma) = G.

Answer by Pasha Zusmanovich for Is S_6 the automorphism group of a group?

2009-11-01T08:16:01Z

There is a whole array of results, going back to G. Birkhoff at 1930s saying that every group is an automorphism group of some universal algebra (or some universal algebra inside some class).
(This really should be merely a comment to the previous answer, but I am still not reputable enough to leave comments).